A Complete Guide to Implementing QAPI in Nursing Homes

The Affordable Care Act’s Section 6102(c) mandated the implementation of Quality Assurance and Performance Improvement (QAPI) programs in all skilled nursing homes. It laid the groundwork for the Centers for Medicare & Medical Services (CMS) to mobilize best practices, anticipating new QAPI regulations under Section 6102(c). October 2016 saw CMS revising the Requirements of Participation (RoP), marking the start of a data-driven approach for effective, comprehensive QAPI programs.

Addressing the prior gap in Quality Assessment and Assurance (QAA) provisions, CMS emphasized accountability in QAPI processes for nursing homes. The aim? Sustaining both the quality of care and residents’ quality of life. CMS established a QAPI program, setting standards and providing technical assistance for best practice development. This expansion meant nursing homes had to continuously identify and solve issues, ensuring ongoing performance improvement.

This blog will dive into what the QAPI program specifically means for nursing homes and provide comprehensive guidelines for implementation.

What is QAPI for Nursing Homes?

QAPI is a combination of two complementary healthcare approaches: quality assurance (QA) and performance improvement (PI).

Quality assurance is about setting and maintaining standards. QA is proactive and retrospective, continually assessing care against established benchmarks. Performance improvement, or quality improvement (QI) is about continuously enhancing healthcare processes to improve outcomes while minimizing the risk of issues.

QA and PI combine to create QAPI, a comprehensive, data-driven approach focused on improving the quality of care.

These key elements include the following.

1. Design and scope
2. Governance and leadership
3. Performance improvement projects (PIPs)
4. Feedback, data systems, and monitoring
5. Systematic analysis and action

Understanding QAPI for Nursing Homes

Quality Challenges in Nursing Homes

Recent studies reveal concerning statistics: approximately 93% of nursing homes received at least one deficiency citation during inspections in 2015. This rate has remained relatively constant since 2005, highlighting ongoing issues in nursing homes.

Additionally, 21% of nursing homes reported serious quality violations in 2015. This is a slight improvement over time, but still a significant concern.

The quality of care tends to vary based on the type of nursing home. Non-profit nursing homes generally offer higher care quality compared to for-profit counterparts. Moreover, nursing homes serving higher concentrations of minority residents often face more quality issues. These disparities highlight the need for targeted improvements in specific areas of the nursing home sector.

• Staffing is a Central Challenge

One of the critical factors influencing nursing home care quality is staffing. Higher nurse staffing levels are typically associated with better care quality. However, federal staffing requirements haven’t been updated since 1987, despite research and expert recommendations advocating for higher standards. The introduction of payroll reporting for staffing data aims to enhance monitoring and accuracy, but challenges remain.

• Financial and Demographic Pressures

Nursing homes are grappling with financial pressures due to thin operating margins and inadequate Medicaid reimbursement. Coupled with a declining private-pay population, these financial challenges are significant. Furthermore, the overall number of residents requiring skilled nursing is decreasing by about 1% per year, partly due to the growth in home healthcare services. These demographic shifts are reshaping the demand for inpatient nursing care.

• The Changing Nature of Care

Nursing facilities are increasingly accepting patients with higher acuity levels. It places additional demands on nursing homes, requiring more specialized care and resources. Additionally, upcoming penalties related to hospital readmissions are another concern for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), adding to the already complex operational challenges.

Developing and Implementing QAPI in Nursing Homes

The QAPI regulation was incorporated into the “Medicare and Medicaid Programs; Reform of the Requirements for Long-Term Care Facilities” rule. It was finalized and published on October 4, 2016. Eventually, nursing homes were required to have their QAPI plan in place and begin implementing QAPI by November 28, 2017.

Resources to prepare QAPI implementation

Here are some helpful QAPI documents and templates from the CMS, that nursing homes should use to prepare for QAPI implementation:

• QAPI Written Plan How-To Guide: This document includes detailed suggestions on how to define the purpose, a list of services, and quality assessment, along with a framework outlining their QAPI activities.
• Guide for Developing Purpose, Guiding Principles, and Scope for QAPI: This helps the team and senior leadership in establishing the purpose, guiding principles, and scope to tailor their QAPI plan to their facility.
• Guide for Developing a QAPI Plan: This is a living document for facilities to meet and achieve their goals previously identified in their purpose and guiding principles. This helpful guide outlines the roles and responsibilities of staff with clear instructions so they can carry out their tasks easily.
• Goal Setting Worksheet: This worksheet allows nursing facilities to measure their performance. It guides their QAPI teams with realistic goals and PIPs so they can accomplish their goals.

For the complete list of CMS QAPI resources, visit CMS resources.

Once the team starts developing the QAPI plan, there will be some concrete steps to QAPI implementation:

• Determine the Focus Area

Engage your team in identifying the areas of quality monitoring and improvement, such as infection prevention. For that, you can use customizable digital checklists from the GoAudits library. In addition to the QAPI plan template and QAPI self-assessment checklists, there are other healthcare audit checklists that you can tailor to assess specific aspects of nursing home operations. It ensures a thorough evaluation aligned with the facility’s mission and current challenges.

• Establish Goals, Measures, and Benchmarks

You will need tools to support real-time data capture and analysis of data across your nursing facility. GoAudits reporting features can support the establishment of clear goals and the tracking of progress against outcomes, processes, and benchmarks, facilitating system-wide improvement.

• Identify and Mitigate Potential Barriers

Systematically identify barriers to improvement, such as staffing challenges or resource limitations. Develop strategies to overcome these barriers.

• Finalize and Implement Your QAPI Plan

With your plan outlined, including identified goals and mitigation strategies, seek approval from the administration and implement the plan. This may involve educating staff about new processes.

• Analyze Data and Adapt

Regularly assess the effectiveness of the QAPI plan using collected data. The advanced analytics dashboard by GoAudits offers a comprehensive view of the data collected through the QAPI program. It helps you regularly assess the QAPI plan’s effectiveness, allowing for data-driven decision-making and continuous process improvement.

As you implement QAPI for long-term care and nursing homes, it’s essential to not only follow the outlined steps but also integrate proven performance improvement methods given below.

Here are some performance improvement methods:

• Six Sigma (DMAIC Model): This approach focuses on data and statistical analysis to define, measure, analyze, improve, and control a process.
• PDSA Cycle (Plan, Do, Study, Act): This is a widely used method involving planning a change, implementing it on a small scale, studying the results, and then acting on what is learned.

Implementing a QAPI program in any healthcare setting requires a comprehensive approach that involves all staff members, from leadership to frontline caregivers.

QAPI Plan Examples and Templates for Nursing Homes

The GoAudits healthcare library offers a range of checklists designed to improve compliance and quality of care across various healthcare settings.

• Nursing Audit
• Patient Satisfaction Survey
• Resident Satisfaction Survey Template
• Patient Fall Risk Assessment
• Weekly Care Plan Audit
• Patient Care Audit

Healthcare fraud and abuse in nursing homes are significant issues impacting the quality of care and financial integrity of healthcare systems. These malpractices can lead to increased costs, reduced quality of patient care, and loss of trust in healthcare institutions. Fraud involves knowingly executing or attempting to execute a scheme to obtain money or property under false pretenses, while abuse refers to practices that may directly or indirectly result in unnecessary costs to the Medicare program, not meeting professional standards.

In nursing homes, fraud and abuse can take various forms, including:

• Billing for services not rendered or providing unnecessary services to increase reimbursement
• Submitting false or inflated claims for reimbursement
• Accepting kickbacks or bribes in exchange for referrals or services
• Providing substandard care or neglecting residents to save costs
• Falsifying resident records or medical charts

These fraudulent and abusive practices not only harm residents and their families but also undermine the financial viability of nursing homes and the healthcare system as a whole. QAPI programs are critical in preventing healthcare fraud and abuse in nursing homes.

QAPI regulations require nursing homes to implement a comprehensive program that includes:

• Establishing policies and procedures to prevent and detect fraud and abuse
• Providing training to staff on fraud and abuse prevention
• Conducting regular audits and monitoring to identify potential fraud and abuse
• Reporting suspected fraud and abuse to the appropriate authorities

Implementing QAPI programs can help prevent fraud and abuse by:

• Promoting Transparency: Regular audits, performance assessments, and reporting can uncover discrepancies and potential areas of fraud or abuse early on.
• Enhancing Accountability: By setting clear expectations for care standards and outcomes, QAPI programs hold staff and management accountable for their actions and decisions.
• Improving Documentation: Thorough and accurate documentation of resident care activities, as encouraged by QAPI, can prevent fraudulent billing and inappropriate care practices.
• Facilitating Continuous Improvement: QAPI’s focus on continuous improvement helps create a culture of excellence and integrity, reducing the risk of unethical practices.
• Engaging Staff and Residents: Involving staff and residents in quality improvement activities fosters a sense of ownership and responsibility, which can deter fraudulent and abusive behaviors.

Is QAPI for Nursing Homes Helping it or Hindering Its Growth?

Skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) are tasked with tracking numerous clinical, financial standards, and quality measures for both internal benchmarking and government compliance. The sheer volume of data generated by SNFs of all sizes presents a unique challenge and opportunity.

GoAudits offers a comprehensive healthcare auditing solution that simplifies data collection, allowing SNFs to easily conduct regular audits on clinical and financial standards. It not only helps in internal benchmarking but also ensures adherence to compliance standards, making the data management process more efficient and less error-prone.

This feature is crucial for SNFs to understand their performance in real-time and make informed decisions to enhance quality measures.

Satisfied residents and their families are more likely to recommend your nursing facility and contribute to your Five-Star rating. Implement strategies to improve the customer experience, including effective communication, personalized care plans, and a welcoming environment. Regularly solicit feedback and actively address concerns to enhance overall satisfaction.

Role of Nurse Assessment Coordinators (NACs) in QAPI

Nurse assessment coordinators (NACs) play an important role in the quality assurance and performance improvement process in nursing homes. They are responsible for monitoring and providing data that should be reviewed during QAPI meetings, including Quality Measure data and Certification and Survey Provider Enhanced Reports (CASPER) reports. NACs also translate data into meaningful information so the QAPI committee can identify real or potential issues and determine if a performance improvement plan (PIP) is needed.

• Data Monitoring and Reporting
  • NACs are responsible for monitoring and providing data that should be reviewed during QAPI meetings.
  • They often generate and analyze reports such as the MDS assessments and Certification and Survey Provider Enhanced Reports (CASPER) reports.
• Translating Data into Meaningful Information
  • NACs go beyond simply presenting data. They translate complex data into meaningful information that the QAPI committee can comprehend.
  • This enables the committee to identify real or potential issues and make informed decisions.
• Identifying Opportunities for Improvement
  • NACs review reports and identify irregularities, errors, or trends that can lead to opportunities for performance improvement.
  • They analyze data over time to detect even slight changes that may indicate underlying problems.
• Providing Suggestions and Analysis in QAPI Meetings
  • NACs bring forth areas that need improvement, supported by data and analysis.
  • They present whether these issues require a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) and suggest possible action plans.
  • NACs contribute to discussions by analyzing data points, such as the frequency and timing of falls, to narrow down the root cause of issues.
• Participating in Performance Improvement Projects (PIPs)
  • NACs may be part of the PIP committee that seeks improvement options using models like the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) model or Fishbone Diagram.
  • They help test improvements, evaluate their effectiveness, and monitor their sustainability over time.
• Ensuring Continuous Monitoring and Improvement:
  • NACs contribute to the facility’s goal of continuous quality improvement by monitoring areas that have been worked on and ensuring sustained success.
  • They play a crucial role in improving the quality of care & quality of life for residents.

Factors Influencing the Quality of Care in Nursing Homes

Here are some of the major factors influencing the quality of care in nursing homes:

• Quality Measurement and Quality Improvement

The CMS Five-Star Rating System for nursing homes plays a crucial role in determining the quality of care in nursing homes. It evaluates nursing homes based on health inspections, staffing levels, and clinical outcomes. However, this system has a significant gap—it does not account for the resident and family experience. This omission highlights the need for a more holistic approach to quality measurement, one that integrates the perspectives of those directly receiving care.

• Nursing Home Workforce

Nursing homes face critical challenges such as workforce shortages, high turnover rates, and often, suboptimal working conditions. The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated these issues. These workforce challenges directly impact the quality of care, emphasizing the need for strategies to improve staff retention, ensure adequate staffing levels, and provide fair compensation and working conditions.

• Nursing Home Environment and Safety

The physical environment greatly influences the quality of life and safety of residents. Many facilities, designed decades ago, do not meet contemporary standards for high-quality care. Issues like shared rooms, inadequate air filtration, and limited outdoor access can detrimentally impact resident well-being. Modernizing these environments and addressing safety concerns, including infection control and medications, are crucial for improving overall care quality.

• Financing and Payment

The financing structure of nursing homes, heavily reliant on Medicaid and Medicare, has profound implications for quality. This structure often limits competition and incentives for quality improvement. Nursing homes primarily serving Medicaid beneficiaries tend to be under-resourced, affecting their ability to provide quality care. The rising cost of care and the projected increase in demand highlight an urgent need for sustainable financing solutions.

• Ownership

Ownership types, ranging from for-profit to non-profit and government-owned, significantly influence the quality of care. Historically, for-profit nursing homes and those owned by private equity firms have shown lower quality outcomes. This suggests a need for closer scrutiny of ownership models and their impact on care standards.

• Quality Assurance (Oversight and Regulation)

Regulatory standards, primarily by CMS and state agencies, are critical for maintaining care standards. However, the consistent presence of deficiencies in areas like infection control and quality of care indicates that the current regulatory framework may need strengthening or reform to effectively uphold high care standards.

• Health Information Technology

Effective use of electronic health records, telehealth, and other technologies can enhance patient safety, care effectiveness, and efficiency. The pandemic has underscored the importance of these technologies in facilitating care and maintaining connections with family members during lockdowns.

What are the Benefits of Implementing QAPI for nursing homes?

Let’s dive into the many benefits of implementing QAPI for nursing homes.

• Reducing Medical Errors

One of the most crucial aspects of QAPI is its role in reducing medical errors. By fostering a culture of continuous improvement, QAPI helps nursing homes identify potential error sources and implement strategies to mitigate them. This not only enhances patient safety but also builds trust and confidence in the healthcare system.

• Elevating Care to Meet Quality and Standards

QAPI pushes healthcare services to new heights of quality and standards. By focusing on continuous improvement and quality assurance, nursing homes can deliver services that are not just good, but exemplary. It ensures that every patient receives the best possible care.

• Transforming Resident Care and Outcomes

Residents are at the heart of nursing homes. Implementing QAPI means their care gets an upgrade. QAPI leads to improved health outcomes, enhanced quality of life, and overall satisfaction for residents.

• Boosting Staff Satisfaction and Retention

Happy staff equals quality care. QAPI creates an environment where staff feel valued and part of a greater purpose. When staff members are engaged in continuous improvement processes, they feel empowered. This leads to higher job satisfaction and, in turn, improves staff retention.

• Preventing Problems in Healthcare Delivery

QAPI isn’t just about fixing problems; it’s about preventing them from occurring in the first place. By proactively identifying areas of risk and implementing preventative measures, nursing homes can significantly reduce the likelihood of issues arising.

Share this article